Please format properly with quotes, it's hell trying to read your replies to my quotes when you type something this long.

My logic assumes that the loss in queue times to my allies is of lower cost than the saved time of other people who would have to encounter this troll in the future.

Your logic also assumes that reporting and banning this troll will make him stop. This is often not the case and only pushes the troll down to the lower levels for a time. So congrats for moving the problem down the line where only the new players and other trolls have to deal with it.

First. I don't think it's trolling.

Oh okay, if you think it isn't trolling it must clearly not be trolling then. Times like this I wish there was an eye roll emoticon.

I respond only to people who threaten to ruin he game for me and everyone else.

So when these people threaten to ruin your game you do your very best to make sure they ruin it? Seems like a good plan. If Riot IP banned or had any way of permanently preventing players from playing this game I'd say this might actually accomplish something.

They might imagine me raging at my computer at the end of the day for their own benefit, but in the end I imagine that constantly not getting to play the character they want is punishment enough for them.

Oh neat, you're both equally delusional.

The fact that he chose a specific character indicates that he does want to play that character and if you, me, and everyone else consistently shot him down every time that he tried to threaten us to play the character then he would derive a higher benefit from asking nicely.

Actually they pick two characters. X or feed. Most of them are pretty happy to play either role at the time they say it.

The reason this isn't the case is that people like you let these jerks have what they want enough to compensate for the times that people don't let them have what they want. The way I see it, I harm at maximum three people a given time I choose to call a feeder's bluff. You harm the entire community when you don't.

Cute but sadly wrong. The problem here is Riot isn't interested in keeping horrible people away from their game. If they were they would at least attempt a form of permanent banishment from the game. I mean yeah being a vigilante may save some lives but it's pointless if the cops in the town are complete shit. Instead of wasting energy fighting an endless battle with the sea of trolls why don't you put your time and effort to something that will actually matter? Like posting or emailing Riot about this issue. I have a feeling if all the would be vigilantes in this thread got together and started to make some noise in the forums you'd get a lot closer to a real solution than just playing whack a mole in game.